| Father Francis J. Rudolf | July 1, 1870 – 1881 |
| Father Francis Torbeck | 1881 – July 6, 1886 |
| Father Adelrich Kaelin | July 7, 1886 – October 24, 1917 |
| Father George Borries | October 28, 1917 – March 9, 1922 |
| Father John Rager | March 25, 1922 – November 1936 |
| Father Clement Zepf | November 1936 – October 1953 |
| Father Bernard Burgert | October 1953 – August 1971 |
| Father Edward McLaughlin | September 1971 – September 1977 |
| Father William Ernst | September 1977 – July 3, 1985 |
| Father Daniel Armstrong | July 3, 1985 – July 7, 1986 |
| Father John Maung | July 7, 1986 – 1998 |
| Father John Fink | 1999 – July 2, 2003 |
| Father Don Quinn | July 2, 2003 – July 3, 2007 |
| Father Chris Craig | July 3, 2007 – July 6, 2011 |
| Father Aaron Pfaff | July 6, 2011 – July 6, 2016 |
| Father Martin Rodriguez | July 6, 2016 – March 26, 2017 |
| Father Joseph Newton | March 27, 2017 – July 5, 2017 |
| Father Michael Keucher | July 5, 2017 – |
